Opinion: Punishment That Doesn’t Fit the Crime, July 30, 2016
By Eric Berkowitz
Matthew and his parents agreed to a guilty plea in exchange for two years of probation, which he spent in a foster home. (His brother also pleaded guilty.) When he returned to his family, they were stunned to learn that he was listed on the
registry website, and would be for 10 years. He was just 13 years old.
Neighbors threw a Molotov cocktail at his house and shot and killed his
family’s dog. Local newspapers listed him by name along with adult sex offender
“monsters” in the area. Texas
He soon “hated life, hated everybody.” Their sons’ ordeals shattered their parents’ marriage of two decades. Matthew dropped out of high school, ran away, was homeless for two years, sank into drugs and served time for burglary and parole violations.
His decade on the registry had ended by 2011, but internet searches continued to show him on the list — and still do. Even worse, his parole included restrictions suitable to a serial child rapist. He was barred from any unsupervised and unapproved contacts with people under 17, and from any contact with his sister, who was by then an adult. (She says she never considered him a threat.) He also was barred from contact with the children of the woman he married in 2013. Even contact with the baby the couple had together was in limbo until he passed a sex offender evaluation.
Sitting in his small, immaculate house in
, with children running over
to hug him, Mr. Grottalio, now a soft-spoken construction worker, hardly seems
a menace. His parole ended a few months ago, but the fallout from his childhood
mistake continues. “It’s just hard to get close to people,” said his wife,
Jennifer. “At P.T.A. meetings, at churches, people still do background checks.” Granbury,
Mr. Grottalio’s story is not unusual. In about 40 states, juveniles are listed on sex offender registries, often for their entire lives. In about 19 states, there is no minimum registration age. Prepubescent children are listed along with violent adult sex criminals. While precise data is unavailable, it appears that as many as 24,000 of the nation’s more than 800,000 registered sex offenders are juveniles, and about 16 percent of that population are younger than 12 years old. More than one-third are 12 to 14.
Many of the kids branded as sex offenders are guilty of nothing worse than public urination, exposing themselves or having consensual sex. In her career as a criminal defense lawyer for juveniles and a researcher on juvenile sex offenders, Nicole Pittman, now a vice president at Impact Justice, defended or reviewed about 2,000 juvenile sex cases. Most involved what she called “normative” sexual behavior and “experimentation.” Nevertheless, on many sex offender websites, there are juveniles’ photos, names and addresses, and even maps to their homes.
It started in the late 1980s and early 1990s, when several child abductions and murders set off a panicked explosion of sex offender laws. The lists were expanded and put on the internet, while the number of registrable offenses grew and restrictions on sex offenders’ lives multiplied. Add to this the prevailing (and later debunked) idea that there were remorseless juvenile “superpredators” roaming the cities and “kids were swept up in the general hysteria,” said Elizabeth Letourneau, director of the Moore Center for the Prevention of Child Sexual Abuse at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. The idea took hold that kids who transgressed sexually were the same as adult sex offenders.
By 2006, about 32 states had sex offender laws registering juveniles. That year, the federal Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act mandated, for the first time, that certain youths 14 and over be registered in the state where the violation occurred. (Once that happens, the person also goes on the national registry.) The law also said that offenses such as indecent exposure and public urination had to be included. At least six states now require juveniles to be on the register for life. Given that state and federal laws have grown into an often conflicting tangle of requirements and penalties, there can be no end to some kids’ ordeals.
Take Josh D., who was molested by an uncle when he was 11 or 12. Soon afterward, he had sex with a younger cousin. “I acted out what was done to me,” he said. At 13, he was placed on the
Delaware registry for 10
years and sent for two years of treatment in . He returned to South Carolina and finished
high school in 2007 with a 3.7 grade point average. In 2014, he entered Delaware Wilmington University
but soon received a letter from the school telling him to stay off campus. Delaware
The reason? He was still on
registry (the state had by then extended the number of years offenders were on
its registry to 15 years or more) and he hadn’t formally notified the school.
Had the school looked further, it would have found that he was also on Delaware Virginia’s and ’s registries. He had lived in South
Carolina Virginia for eight years with his mother, and any sex
offender who goes to
for more than 30 days appears on its registry. In 2014, judges and officials in
South Carolina Delaware and agreed to take his name off of
their states’ registries. Virginia
“It’s like the government wants me to be a monster,” he said.
Bobby Garza’s lifetime involvement with the criminal justice system started 20 years ago with a broken bathroom light bulb. Scared of entering the dark bathroom of their
, house, 11-year-old Bobby and his
brother went to urinate outside. A little girl saw them and reported that Bobby
and his brother had exposed themselves to her. A charge for indecent exposure
to a child resulted, as did Bobby’s placement in a foster home. He fled when an
adult in the foster home tried to molest him, which led to his being held in
custody, including youth prison, until he was 17. Upon release, he had to
register as a sex offender for 10 years. He refused, and spent five years in
prison for it. In 2013, he was arrested for aggravated robbery, for which he
pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 10 years in prison. Taylor, Tex.
“I was robbed of my childhood,” he said in a letter from prison.
The expansion of sex offender laws to include juveniles was based on the assumption that kids who sexually transgress cannot be reformed. However, research has shown this assumption to be false. Only 1 percent to 7 percent of children who commit sexual offenses will do it again — much lower than the 13 percent recidivism rates for adult sexual offenders.
The policy seems to succeed only in making life difficult for offenders, subjecting them to harassment and isolation. Of the more than 500 youth sex offenders whose cases Ms. Pittman examined, about 100 had attempted suicide. “If you wanted to make things worse, we could not have designed a better policy,” Ms. Letourneau said.
Knowing this, prosecutors like Vicki Seidl, the senior lawyer in the juvenile division of the
district attorney’s office in ,
now push for pleas that keep youths off registries. Other prosecutors are
following suit. Michigan
But that alone will not solve the problem. Juveniles, particularly ones under 14, need to be off the registries entirely. In 2011, the Department of Justice relaxed the requirement for registering juveniles, but legislators still fear that they’ll be accused of being “soft” on sex crimes.
Matthew Grottalio, who has had a second child with Jennifer, has decided to stop trying to keep his story secret. “I have two boys now and I don’t want the same thing to happen to them, or to anyone,” he said. “I just can’t sit around and act like it never happened. I want to do something about it.”